Home » letters » Flawed accusations

Flawed accusations

I AM writing in response to comments made in the media by Labor Senator Jana Stewart on the Parliamentary Committee considering an Indigenous Voice to Parliament (Webster comments ‘mislead’, senator says, The Guardian, May 30).

Senator Stewart’s accusations, platformed by this publication, show a distinct lack of respect for both the debate and for those whose views do not align with her own.

Politics is replete with those willing to sing from the government song-sheet to push an agenda detached from the facts.

The simple fact is this: the public positions of those on the committee were known when they were appointed, and the committee was made up of 10 publicly stated pro-Voice members and just three not in support of the Voice. That is hardly a balanced committee.

Senator Stewart is clutching at straws citing Andrew Gee “former National” to imply some sort of even-handedness. Mr Gee quit The Nationals over his position on the Voice, but I can tell you confidently an overwhelming majority of Mallee residents surveyed oppose the Voice for the reasons I have previously outlined, as has the National party.

The government achieved its desired outcome with the committee from a relatively low number of submissions, compared to the number of submissions on many Parliamentary inquiries and committees I have been a member. This referendum, if successful, will trigger the biggest change to our Constitution and expansion of bureaucracy in living memory.

On the day of the referendum, the views of all Australian citizens will be known.

My hope is that facts and reason drive the debate that informs the views and decides the vote on this critical issue, not flawed political accusations.

Dr Anne Webster

Member for Mallee

Digital Editions


  • Eagles soar to second spot

    Eagles soar to second spot

    A DOMINANT second quarter has helped the Mallee Eagles claim their third straight win, with the Eagles defeating Tyntynder by 39 goals at Lalbert on…

More News

  • Have your say on water services

    Have your say on water services

    IRRIGATORS across the Nyah, Tresco and Woorinen districts have been urged to have their say on the future of their water services, as Goulburn-Murray Water released draft strategy summaries for…

  • Swans top table

    Swans top table

    BOTH the Swan Hill men’s and women’s soccer teams continue to top their respective ladders after they secured points from matches at the Ken Harrison Reserve this weekend. While the…

  • Eagles return to winners list

    Eagles return to winners list

    The Mallee Eagles have responded in emphatic fashion to their disappointing 47-point defeat to NNW United by thrashing Tyntynder by 127 points at Lalbert on Saturday. Despite the final margin,…

  • Financial pressures

    Financial pressures

    RATEPAYERS have been urged to brace for tough financial decisions as Swan Hill Rural City Council unveiled a $36 million draft capital works budget while warning of rising costs, shrinking…

  • State lifts performance orders

    State lifts performance orders

    BALRANALD Shire Council has finally emerged from nearly a decade of State Government oversight, with the NSW Government confirming the closure of long-running performance improvement orders imposed over governance and…

  • Food scrap bins mandatory

    Food scrap bins mandatory

    HOUSEHOLDS across the Swan Hill region are set for a major shake-up to their rubbish collection, with food scraps and garden waste bins to become mandatory under a new state…

  • Satisfaction survey launch

    Satisfaction survey launch

    RESIDENTS across the Murray River Council area are being urged to have their say as part of a new community satisfaction survey launching later this month. Chief executive Stacy Williams…

  • Cancer fundraiser

    Cancer fundraiser

    SWAN Hill is set to rally for a good cause, with the Swan Hill Racecourse Bowls Club hosting a heartfelt Cuppa for Cancer fundraiser next Tuesday. Sponsored by Any Occasion…

  • Headspace marks IDAHOBIT

    Headspace marks IDAHOBIT

    LAST Friday, Headspace Swan Hill partnered with the team at Swan Hill Regional Library and Youth Inc to bring Dragged To to town, a free Drag Bingo event for those…

  • News from Moulamein

    News from Moulamein

    Mighty Magoo’s celebrate IT’S been about two years since the Mighty Magoo’s have had the chance to sing the club song, so it was a pretty special moment. As we…