Home » letters » ‘You can’t have your cake and eat it to’

‘You can’t have your cake and eat it to’

WHEN I read an ABC article featuring what they referred to as “waterlogged land” in South Australia’s south-east being turned into an “agricultural engine room”, I didn’t know whether to laugh or cry.

If there had been sufficient research for this article, the author would have discovered that these south-east drains are the primary reason for the environmental degradation of the Coorong, which led to the Murray-Darling Basin Plan.

So now, we channel water from Hume and Dartmouth dams to the Lower Lakes, Coorong and Murray Mouth to try to repair the damage that has been caused by the very state that wants upstream communities to come to their rescue.

And it’s all at the cost of agriculture, jobs and prosperity upstream, in particular the mid-Murray regions in Victoria and NSW, not to mention increased prices at the supermarket for everyone.

Effectively, South Australians want the eastern states to repair their damage by demanding that undeliverable volumes are sent down the Murray River, and with clever political tactics they have conned the Federal Government into acquiescing.

The Sydney-based new Environment and Water Minister Tanya Plibersek is complicit in a plan that Australians will live to regret.

There’s a saying that “you can’t have your cake and eat it too”.

It seems that does not apply if you are in South Australia.

Shelley Scoullar,

Albury

Digital Editions


  • Budget splash leaves Swan Hill empty-handed

    Budget splash leaves Swan Hill empty-handed

    SWAN Hill has been left out in the cold in the 2026/27 Victorian budget, despite a multibillion-dollar focus on easing cost-of-living pressures. Treasurer Jaclyn Symes…

More News

  • Celebrating the heart of healthcare

    Celebrating the heart of healthcare

    SWAN Hill District Health is proud to celebrate and acknowledge the remarkable dedication, skill and compassion of its midwives and nurses as part of International Day of the Midwife and…

  • Cinema for a cause

    Cinema for a cause

    A NIGHT of fun, chocolate, and community service was on the cards for the hundreds of locals who flocked to Showbiz Cinemas last Thursday for Inner Wheel’s 12th annual movie…

  • No funding for schools

    No funding for schools

    MEMBER for Murray Plains Peter Walsh has accused the Victorian Government of pork barrelling, alleging schools in his safe seat have been shut out of funding in the 2026–27 state…

  • Meeting clash rejected

    Meeting clash rejected

    A PUSH to scrap a Murray River Council meeting during peak farming season has been shot down, with one councillor told to just put in an apology. Cr Kylie Berryman…

  • Not guilty plea for hit and run

    Not guilty plea for hit and run

    A PIANGIL man alleged to have deliberately run over another man in a 4WD before stabbing a woman in February this year has pleaded not guilty ahead of a County…

  • Blazing a trail

    Blazing a trail

    Racecourse lawn bowler Alannah Taylor is helping reshape perceptions of the sport locally, after representing Vic Country last weekend against several of Australia’s top competitors. With a new generation of…

  • Tigers thrash disappointing Saints

    Tigers thrash disappointing Saints

    SEA Lake Nandaly continued their unbeaten start to 2026 with a dominant 91-point win over St Arnaud thanks to an outstanding display of ball use, according to Tigers co-coach Wade…

  • Teachers pause strike plans

    Teachers pause strike plans

    VICTORIAN teachers have agreed to pause rolling stop work actions for two weeks in a bid to maximize negotiation efforts. Negotiations between the government and Australian Education Union’s Victoria Branch…

  • Surprise arrival for family

    Surprise arrival for family

    KERANG mum of two Tahkirra Chambers and partner Luke Russell are still enjoying the newborn bubble with week-old Marley, who made a surprise entry to the family three weeks early.…

  • Farrer by-election candidates

    Farrer by-election candidates

    Raissa Butkowski (Liberal) ALBURY City Councillor and lawyer Raissa Butkowski has focused on cost of living for her by-election campaign. The Liberal hopeful was confirmed a month after Sussan Ley’s…