Home » letters » ‘You can’t have your cake and eat it to’

‘You can’t have your cake and eat it to’

WHEN I read an ABC article featuring what they referred to as “waterlogged land” in South Australia’s south-east being turned into an “agricultural engine room”, I didn’t know whether to laugh or cry.

If there had been sufficient research for this article, the author would have discovered that these south-east drains are the primary reason for the environmental degradation of the Coorong, which led to the Murray-Darling Basin Plan.

So now, we channel water from Hume and Dartmouth dams to the Lower Lakes, Coorong and Murray Mouth to try to repair the damage that has been caused by the very state that wants upstream communities to come to their rescue.

And it’s all at the cost of agriculture, jobs and prosperity upstream, in particular the mid-Murray regions in Victoria and NSW, not to mention increased prices at the supermarket for everyone.

Effectively, South Australians want the eastern states to repair their damage by demanding that undeliverable volumes are sent down the Murray River, and with clever political tactics they have conned the Federal Government into acquiescing.

The Sydney-based new Environment and Water Minister Tanya Plibersek is complicit in a plan that Australians will live to regret.

There’s a saying that “you can’t have your cake and eat it too”.

It seems that does not apply if you are in South Australia.

Shelley Scoullar,

Albury

Digital Editions


  • Anglers reel in 260 fish

    Anglers reel in 260 fish

    River to drop Normally I leave this till the river levels but this time I thought I had better put it up the top. The…

More News

  • All abilities netball scores goal

    All abilities netball scores goal

    Netball for people of all abilities continues to grow in popularity, with a new program launching at the Swan Hill Stadium on Monday, March 2, with the program supported by…

  • Fuel retailers under scrutiny

    Fuel retailers under scrutiny

    STATE and federal governments have implemented measures to prevent fuel retailers ripping off customers. Under the next phase of the Victorian Government Fair Fuel Plan, retailers are now required to…

  • Celebration of cultural tapestries

    Celebration of cultural tapestries

    GRATITUDE and belonging were the first words which sprung into writer Patrick Tucker’s mind when asked about Portraits of Many Paths, which was launched in Swan Hill and Robinvale. Mr…

  • Diesel dilemma

    Diesel dilemma

    SURGING demand, not a lack of fuel landing on Australian shores, has caused prices to soar and bowsers to run dry this week, industry leaders and government ministers agree. Prices…

  • Hosking calls time on VFF presidency

    Hosking calls time on VFF presidency

    VICTORIAN Farmers Federation president Brett Hosking will step down at the end of his term, saying it is time for a new generation to lead the farming lobby after helping…

  • Emergency drill tests safety procedures

    Emergency drill tests safety procedures

    A PLANNED emergency training exercise at Swan Hill Town Hall saw emergency services and council staff rehearse evacuation and response procedures on Wednesday. The exercise was organised by Swan Hill…

  • Mallee rally routes reviewed

    Mallee rally routes reviewed

    ALTERNATIVE routes for the Mallee Rally have been reviewed, according to the Victorian Government. The annual event, held on the bank of Lake Tyrrell, was abruptly stalled in 2019 after…

  • Spikes impacting freight, industry

    Spikes impacting freight, industry

    ROAD freighters warn that rising freight costs will have economy‑wide impacts, with no industry exempt. A Swan Hill Freight Agents spokesperson said the spiking cost of fuel would flow on…

  • Heart of songwriting remains unchanged

    Heart of songwriting remains unchanged

    AUSTRALIAN country music star Sara Storer has spent decades turning everyday bush moments into songs. The stories, she says, are everywhere. You just have to recognise the ones worth telling.…

  • Guns seized

    Guns seized

    A MAN has been charged with multiple firearm offences after police allegedly seized five unregistered guns from a rural property in Koraleigh. NSW Police executed a search warrant at a…