Home » letters » Letters to the Editor: 18/12/20

Letters to the Editor: 18/12/20

It now must be completed

THE Murray Basin Rail Project (MBRP) has been decades in gestation.

In 2007, Tim Fischer (then Deputy Prime Minister) was commissioned by the state government to conduct a review of all country rail lines in Victoria.

Rail lines were graded in importance and, as a result, many lines were closed, whilst others were promised upgrade and standardisation by 2018.

Our own Manangatang line has been in such dangerous condition that freight trains have been able to travel at only 15 to 20 kilometres per hour, for the past 30 years.

The current government in their wisdom, however, have decided otherwise.

Their recommendation in the MBRP business case review (most of with which we strongly disagree), that the project cannot be justified on a “value for money basis”, is particularly galling, disturbing and insulting.

By extension of this statement, we can only take it that we, primary producers, are not valued, either as an industry, a community or even, simply, Victorians who happen to live rurally.

How can Victorian dryland grain growers provide low cost, high quality food to the entire population of Melbourne, put the remaining two thirds of our produce on ships to export around the world, and then be deemed “not value for money”? These excuses only reinforce this misunderstood and unjust situation.

Revised road and rail infrastructure is imperative for the very commercial and social survival of our people.

This rail upgrade will reduce supply chain costs and grow both Victoria’s and Australia’s economy.

The MBRP was planned, promised, and funded. It is a national infrastructure program. It must be completed.

All export grain must go by rail from our region. Rail use will reduce road congestion, risk and pollution in cities, suburbs and ports.

Australia relies on mining and agriculture (50 per cent of our export income) to pay for the vast array of manufactured goods that we, as a country, import.

We farmers feed our cities, but we cannot continue without upgraded transport infrastructure. We, as a people, have very few services or amenities. We have to travel and so does the food we produce.

We are told we are an essential service.

All we ask is that the government treat us that way by providing us with safe, efficient, viable, transport infrastructure. Victorian grain growing districts have had a form of “social and economic apartheid” inflicted upon us with this proposed “mangled plan”.

Over many decades we have lobbied for quality transport infrastructure. Nothing less than the complete standardisation and upgrade of the total MBRP is acceptable.

Brian Barry Snr

Manangatang

Digital Editions


  • Roos secure finals spot

    Roos secure finals spot

    SATURDAY marked the end of another successful regular season for the Balranald Roos C-grade cricket team, whose impressive form has pushed them into third place.…

More News

  • Against all odds

    Against all odds

    A ROGUE Easter fishing trip, three meticulously kept minutes and one fateful, penultimate delivery formed the history-making trinity behind St Mary’s-Tyntynder’s legendary 1985-86 premiership win. St Mary’s-Tyntynder, also known as…

  • Swan Hill paramedics improve response

    Swan Hill paramedics improve response

    AMBULANCE performance in the Swan Hill local government area improved the most in the Loddon Mallee region during the second quarter of 2025/26. Paramedics attended 75.4 per cent of code…

  • Why ASME Standards Matter for APAC Infrastructure Development

    Why ASME Standards Matter for APAC Infrastructure Development

    Infrastructure development is happening at a pace rarely seen. Power stations keep cities running across the Asia Pacific (APAC) region. Manufacturing facilities support jobs and trade. Industrial capacity is scaling…

  • Speak up on school services

    Speak up on school services

    A LOCAL Victorian State MP is encouraging people to share their experiences of education services in the electorate as part of a pledge to support rural students. Mildura MP Jade…

  • Pool party to make a splash

    Pool party to make a splash

    HEADSPACE Swan Hill will be making a splash on Monday for their 10th birthday, celebrating 10 years of making positive waves in young people’s lives. Entry to the pool will…

  • Heartfelt comedy lands the punchline

    Heartfelt comedy lands the punchline

    In what critics have described as a comedy of remarriage, Is This Thing On? premiered in Swan Hill last Thursday, giving audiences a sneak peek into the inner workings of…

  • Mayor’s column

    Mayor’s column

    A message from Mayor Stuart King Basin Plan review Last week the Murray–Darling Basin Authority released the 2026 Basin Plan Review Discussion Paper – it represents a very important moment…

  • Bowls Notes

    Bowls Notes

    MURRAY DOWNS The last rounds of pennant bowls have now been completed and our club has seven teams playing in the finals. Midweek pennant team 4 defeated the top side…

  • Golf Notes

    Golf Notes

    MURRAY DOWNS MEN’S Par – Thursday, February 5 It was the day before the Murray Downs 2026 Reciprocal Challenge and ‘Smithy’ came to play, with Dale Smith (13) one of…

  • Around the churches

    Around the churches

    Anglican Parishioners will have the option of attending a range of services this weekend. Tonight, there’s the monthly services at Birchip at 5pm, followed by Ultima at 7.30pm. All are…