Home » letters » Letters to the editor

Letters to the editor

Strong deterrent

THE Victorian Government is delivering on our commitment for new laws to protect farmers from animal activists and prevent biosecurity threats.

The Livestock Management Amendment (Animal Activism) Bill 2021 recognises the significant biosecurity risks that trespassing by animal activists can pose and introduces substantial on-the-spot fines to deter these protests.

The Shadow Minister for Agriculture, Peter Walsh, is deliberately misleading our farmers with his false claims about these new laws.

Victoria’s on-the-spot fines for animal activists who trespass on farms will be the toughest in the nation.

Those caught trespassing on livestock premises could receive on-the-spot fines of $1272 for an individual or $8718 for an organisation.

These penalties are more severe than New South Wales’ on-the-spot fine of $1000 or Queensland’s $689 fine. Additionally, Victoria is the only state in Australia that proposes a specific infringement offence for an organisation.

We are protecting our farmers and agricultural businesses – as well as their families – from the biosecurity risks and distress that breaches from trespassers can pose.

Mr Walsh’s comments regarding river frontages demonstrate a total lack of understanding of these laws. Crown river frontages which have been leased by farmers are in fact included in these laws and may be subject to a Biosecurity Management Plan (BMP).

The amendment to the legislation put forward by the Nationals would apply to licensed, not leased land. Far from impacting animal activists, this would actually restrict public access to river fronts for activities such as fishing.

It’s regrettable that Mr Walsh fails to understand the difference between licensed and leased land and the different laws that apply.

We are backing our hard-working farmers because they are critical to keeping food on the table and supporting local jobs in regional and rural communities across Victoria.

Farmers and workers in the agricultural industry should be able to do their work without fear of being targeted by animal activists. This sort of activity is highly distressing for farming families and puts the biosecurity and safety of the animals that activists purport to protect at risk.

Our legislation delivers a strong deterrent and significant penalties, making it crystal clear that this behaviour is unacceptable.

Mary-Anne Thomas,

Minister for Agriculture

Mayhem and massacre

THE Victorian Government has decreed that yet another duck shooting season will go ahead; another season of warfare on our waterbirds.

This despite the facts about the ongoing and serious decline in waterbird numbers including “game” ducks.

This despite the majority of Victorians being opposed to duck shooting.

Who benefits from this duck shooting season:

  • It certainly isn’t our waterbirds who are being treated with casual and shocking cruelty;
  • It isn’t regional towns and farming families or residents living close to waterways, rivers and wetlands where shooting is happening;
  • It isn’t our natural environment, and;
  • It isn’t the greater population of this state.

If shooters need to kill something, perhaps they might like to target the deer, rabbits, foxes and cats that are decimating our farming enterprises as well as our wildlife.

This, however, would mean proper skilled hunting, not just shooting sitting ducks.

Are the shooters capable?

So, Mr Andrews, just why is this season going ahead? Come clean.

Tell us, who has your government over this bloodstained barrel and why your government thinks it can ignore the scientific facts, the destruction of our valuable wildlife and environment and the wishes of the majority.

Anne Hughes,

St Arnaud Field Naturalist Club

Digital Editions


  • Online policing forum

    Online policing forum

    POLICE are urging residents across the region to log on and speak up at this year’s online Neighbourhood Policing Forum. The annual forum, hosted by…

More News

  • When law meets life

    When law meets life

    JOURNEY through the people, cases and stories that shaped justice through Swan Hill’s history at the Folk-Law historical exhibition at the Swan Hill Regional Library from Monday, 11 May. The…

  • Revisiting the King of Pop

    Revisiting the King of Pop

    THE highly anticipated biopic Michael hit Showbiz Swan Hill last week, promising an in-depth look at the legendary career of the late Michael Jackson. Prior to the exploration of the…

  • Robinvale flying doctors continues service

    Robinvale flying doctors continues service

    ROYAL Flying Doctor Service’s transport program has received a $3 million boost following support from the Robinvale community. The RFDS’s Community Transport Program officially launched in 2018 as a way…

  • Dreaming big in Swan Hill

    Dreaming big in Swan Hill

    SWAN Hill’s business community has joined together for a month of ideas, innovation and connection. Swan Hill Rural City Council, Swan Hill Incorporated and the Robinvale Euston Business Association have…

  • Around the churches

    Around the churches

    Anglican THE Men’s Shed at Nyah West had a successful sausage sizzle at Bunnings last Saturday. Funds raised will help to pay expenses such as insurance, as well as allow…

  • Bowls Notes

    Bowls Notes

    SWAN HILL The 60th Autumn/May Carnival at the Swan Hill Bowls Club began last Saturday in beautiful sunshine, attracting both local and visiting bowlers and setting the scene for a…

  • Dry April

    Dry April

    SWAN Hill has finally had a drink, but the drought warning signs are far from over. The district recorded just 1.2mm of rain in April, its driest in seven years…

  • New skills and hot brews

    New skills and hot brews

    CUSTOMERS of Swan Hill’s newest cafes can get their morning coffee with a side of supporting budding baristas to learn job-ready skills. My Plan Connect participants have taken up the…

  • Budget gap widens

    Budget gap widens

    SWAN Hill Rural City Council has welcomed parts of the state budget but says regional communities are still being left behind. The council has acknowledged the Victorian Government’s 2026/27 pre-election…

  • Measles detected

    Measles detected

    A FRESH measles warning has been issued after four new cases were recorded across Victoria, including one linked to the Loddon Mallee region. Health authorities said all four cases in…