Home » letters » Letters to the editor

Letters to the editor

Choose vote wisely

DURING the last federal election, Clive Palmer and the United Australia Party spent $80 million on political advertising.

Whilst he did not win a single seat, Clive Palmer had a huge impact on the election outcome by giving preferences to the Coalition.

Political donations are undermining our democracy. They enable those with the deepest pockets to have a massive advantage in getting their message across.

Political donations should be capped and made public in real time so we know who is backing candidates and so that each candidate has the same opportunity to win your vote.

It was disappointing for those who made the effort to attend the candidate’s forum in Swan Hill last Wednesday that the United Australia Party and the Nationals would not tell people who they were giving their preferences to.

Choose your vote wisely and make sure you know who is preferencing who. It can have a major impact on who will lead this country after this election.

Peta Thornton

Woorinen

Thousands in limbo

SCOTT Morrison maintained one of the most brutal lies of Australian politics – that people had to be locked up to save lives at sea.

It was political abuse of the worst kind. Most of the refugees have finally been let out, many after ten years in prison, because they no longer serve any political purpose. Two hundred and twenty are still in detention.

Billions of dollars have been spent to keep this lie alive. Untold numbers of lives have been destroyed.

Those who made it to Australia before the detention lock-ups, aren’t much better off.

Thousands of them are living in limbo, and have been for ten years, many still on Temporary Protection Visas.

Yet most of them have worked full-time for the entire period, despite having been told, “You are an illegal arrival. (They are not) You will never be a citizen. You will never get your families out here to safety. You will never be welcome in Australia”.

Ann Webster has supported this cruel mantra when approached for help.

Show her she does not speak for you and put her last on the ballot paper.

Janet Field

Swan Hill

Careful what you wish for

THE last federal election was only won by the Coalition because the Australian voters rejected Labor’s global warming alarmism policies and yet the Coalition has now changed their global warming policies to be near identical to Labor. Why?

Is it because the Coalition has succumbed to the power and influence of the United Nations and World Economic Forum made up of undemocratically elected global elites who strongly promote a new world order and a drastic reduction in global population?

Any history book will tell you it’s been a lot hotter and colder than currently, and CO2 a lot higher and yet nothing to do with humans.

These new climate policies will devastate regional Australia while China laugh in our face and buy us out to utilise our natural resources for themselves.

Fossil fuels are needed to produce fertiliser and new policies have reduced supplies enormously and prices have skyrocketed four times over the last year.

I know because I’m a farmer. So food, fuel and power prices will continue to increase enormously going forward, so be careful what you wish for.

If you were happy with how Australians were treated over the last two years from the lies and policies put in place to “flatten the curve”, then socialism is for you and you need not worry. The Coalition could have revoked the states’ positions if they wanted but chose to support and encourage them, for which I will never forgive.

But if you are not happy and want Australia to remain a sovereign country with freedom of thought, speech, to protest and to seek a true democratic process, then vote for the freedom party independents (you determine your preference, not the party) and put the major parties last.

Simon Grigg

Patchewollock

Missing in the room

SOPHIE Baldwin says she advocates for water and the environment.

Ms Baldwin, along with all the other known Mallee candidates, was invited to attend a recent Sustainable Living in the Mallee event where the latest science and data was explained from a Mallee perspective.

If she was as passionate as myself and the other candidate who attended, she would have made sure she was in the room.

Ms Baldwin would have been held to account on her self-interest on water and her connection to the Southern Riverina Irrigators (SRI) group, who parachuted her in as a candidate, to put their vested interest on water into government.

We all know there is nothing that stops politicians lying in an election.

So how can Ms Baldwin be trusted on water, when she says one thing, but her conflicting stance and position as SRI executive, says another?

She says she has made her position clear, but we still do not have answers to the question, “What is your relationship with SRI if you say you do not have corporate backers?”

And, given that integrity is the major platform we, as Independents stand for, it is imperative you make this clear and put all of Australia and the electorate first, not just your interests.

This is a classic example of “Look not on what they say, but what they do.”

Claudia Haenel

Independent candidate for Mallee

Stop politicising the LGBTQIA+ community

I AM writing again regarding the comments made by West Wimmera Shire Mayor Bruce Meyer after his council voted against flying the rainbow flag for the International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia, Intersexism and Transphobia (IDAHOBIT).

Despite hearing such awful comments, it’s been heartening the way the LGBTQIA+ and West Wimmera communities have come together in response.

However, I have not heard my federal representative in parliament speak on this issue despite public calls from myself and The Wimmera Pride Project to do so. I need to explain why this causes me so much angst and pain.

Member for Mallee Anne Webster chaired a committee that looked into the federal government’s proposed Religious Discrimination Bill. The Wimmera Pride Project wrote to Dr Webster to express our fear about the legislation (specifically the statements of belief clause) and its power to strip individuals of their right to seek protection under state antidiscrimination law and access to justice in the free state tribunal.

The overriding of state anti-discrimination legislation was unique and unprecedented in 40 plus years of Australian anti-discrimination law. It was described as a sword for

this reason by many people more suitably qualified to speak on the matter than Dr Webster.

The report from the committee that Dr Webster chaired confirmed that our concerns were in fact correct. When the report was released, Dr Webster issued a press release

saying the legislation “struck a fair balance” and was “not a sword”.

Not only was the legislation a sword, it removed the shield the LGBTQIA+ community already had. She abandoned me and other LGBTQIA+ constituents (or anyone seeking the protection of state anti-discrimination law).

While what Bruce Meyer said was abhorrent and I am appreciative of the outrage people showed, we need to remember this was in response to asking council to fly a flag. Flying the flag is an important symbolic gesture that is hugely meaningful to those in the LGBTQIA+ community. However, it does not materially impact the lives of the entire community by restricting our ability to seek equal justice under the law.

What Anne Webster did to my community is just as bad, if not worse,than what Bruce Meyer did. Bruce, at least, was transparent with us.

I invite Dr Webster to prove me wrong. She broke my heart and my trust when she ignored our pleas to scrap the statements of belief clause in the Religious Discrimination Bill.

To all the other candidates for the seat of Mallee, I beg that you vow, should you be elected, to stop politicising the lives of your LGBTQIA+ constituents and focus on more important issues facing the electorate.

Patrick Quaine

Horsham

Digital Editions


  • From dreams to silver springs

    From dreams to silver springs

    THERE’S a special kind of magic required to step into the swirling shawls and unmistakable voice of Stevie Nicks, and for Nikki Canale, it’s a…

More News

  • Saleyard turns profit

    Saleyard turns profit

    THE Swan Hill Regional Livestock Exchange is back in the black and looks set to post a profit for the 2025-26 financial year, after a reversal of financial fortunes in…

  • Final attempt to stop major works

    Final attempt to stop major works

    THE Nyah district community has taken a stand against the planned construction of levees to control the flow of water through the Murray River in Nyah Vinifera Park, which was…

  • Celebrating 102 years

    Celebrating 102 years

    FOUR generations came together at Alcheringa Aged Care Home on Wednesday to celebrate a remarkable milestone, as family matriarch Kathleen ‘Nell’ Flight marked her 102nd birthday. The milestone event brought…

  • Digital Dreamtime

    Digital Dreamtime

    THE Art Gallery of Swan Hill is set to become a meeting place for colour, memory, and Country as Josh Muir’s Forever I Live exhibition opens Friday night. The late…

  • Square set for makeover

    Square set for makeover

    RESIDENTS are being invited to help shape the future of one of Robinvale’s key public spaces as plans progress for a major makeover of the popular Caix Square. The $250,000…

  • Cuppa helps boost support services

    Cuppa helps boost support services

    THE Swan Hill community turned out in full force on Tuesday to support a worthy cause at the Racecourse Bowls Club, with locals gathering for the annual Cuppa for Cancer…

  • Foot chase leads to arrest

    Foot chase leads to arrest

    A MAN accused of a string of domestic violence offences and an aggravated break and enter in the state’s Far West has faced court after a dramatic arrest in Balranald.…

  • New inspector welcomed

    New inspector welcomed

    A VETERAN country cop with deep family ties to the Murray region had stepped into one of the Mallee’s most important policing roles, vowing to keep communities safe while putting…

  • Driving community care

    Driving community care

    MURRAY Downs Golf and Country Club have continued their mission of servicing the community with a $15,000 donation to the Swan Hill Neighborhood House Community Transport Program. The not-for-profit service…

  • Guy announces regional tour

    Guy announces regional tour

    GUY Sebastian is heading back to the regions, with the Australian music superstar announcing a massive national tour that includes a stop in Swan Hill later this year. Fresh off…