Home » letters » Flawed accusations

Flawed accusations

I AM writing in response to comments made in the media by Labor Senator Jana Stewart on the Parliamentary Committee considering an Indigenous Voice to Parliament (Webster comments ‘mislead’, senator says, The Guardian, May 30).

Senator Stewart’s accusations, platformed by this publication, show a distinct lack of respect for both the debate and for those whose views do not align with her own.

Politics is replete with those willing to sing from the government song-sheet to push an agenda detached from the facts.

The simple fact is this: the public positions of those on the committee were known when they were appointed, and the committee was made up of 10 publicly stated pro-Voice members and just three not in support of the Voice. That is hardly a balanced committee.

Senator Stewart is clutching at straws citing Andrew Gee “former National” to imply some sort of even-handedness. Mr Gee quit The Nationals over his position on the Voice, but I can tell you confidently an overwhelming majority of Mallee residents surveyed oppose the Voice for the reasons I have previously outlined, as has the National party.

The government achieved its desired outcome with the committee from a relatively low number of submissions, compared to the number of submissions on many Parliamentary inquiries and committees I have been a member. This referendum, if successful, will trigger the biggest change to our Constitution and expansion of bureaucracy in living memory.

On the day of the referendum, the views of all Australian citizens will be known.

My hope is that facts and reason drive the debate that informs the views and decides the vote on this critical issue, not flawed political accusations.

Dr Anne Webster

Member for Mallee

Digital Editions


  • Tougher penalties for ram-raids

    Tougher penalties for ram-raids

    CRIMINALS behind an alleged ram-raid on a Swan Hill tobacco shop in December could be jailed for up to two decades if found guilty. The…

More News

  • Smash hit

    Smash hit

    Top level tennis will return to Swan Hill next week, with the ITF ProTour Swan Hill Tennis International getting underway from Sunday at the Ken Harrison Reserve. Among those set…

  • Moulamein funding bid

    Moulamein funding bid

    MOULAMEIN could be set for a major infrastructure boost, with Murray River Council backing a nearly $2 million funding application to revitalise the town’s riverfront and key community assets. At…

  • Royal Commission push back

    Royal Commission push back

    A FIERY clash in Federal Parliament has reignited the bitter fight over the future of the Murray-Darling Basin, with the federal environment minister rejecting claims the government is “destroying family…

  • Duck hunting season opens

    Duck hunting season opens

    THE Victorian duck hunting season began this week with a small number of wetlands closed to shooters, but the decision has reignited the long-running battle between hunters and animal welfare…

  • State of disrepair

    State of disrepair

    RESIDENTS and local leaders are calling for the State Government to urgently address “dangerous” and ongoing defects on the Murray Valley Highway between Swan Hill and Kerang. Lake Charm resident…

  • Farmers need fuel

    Farmers need fuel

    CITY dwellers are being urged to swap their cars for public transport and the government to make public transport free as the fuel crisis lingers. Victorian Farmers Federation president Brett…

  • Cultural celebration

    Cultural celebration

    Helen Tuntar’s life has been guided by the values of family, community and care, which she carried from Delta State in Nigeria to Swan Hill. “My life growing up in…

  • Jail for screwdriver threat

    Jail for screwdriver threat

    A SWAN Hill woman who threatened a mother with a screwdriver in a supermarket car park while two young children sat in the car has been jailed. Lilli Buckman was…

  • Big steps forward

    Big steps forward

    THE next major step in revitalising Riverside Park in Swan Hill has been completed, with the famous 10 steps replaced and open to the public. As part of the replacement,…

  • Buloke Lakes – Where the Mallee meets the water

    Buloke Lakes – Where the Mallee meets the water

    Scattered across the Buloke Shire, these much-loved lakes offer a refreshing escape in the heart of the Mallee. From shady freshwater retreats to sandy edged camping spots and iconic salt…