Home » letters » Flawed accusations

Flawed accusations

I AM writing in response to comments made in the media by Labor Senator Jana Stewart on the Parliamentary Committee considering an Indigenous Voice to Parliament (Webster comments ‘mislead’, senator says, The Guardian, May 30).

Senator Stewart’s accusations, platformed by this publication, show a distinct lack of respect for both the debate and for those whose views do not align with her own.

Politics is replete with those willing to sing from the government song-sheet to push an agenda detached from the facts.

The simple fact is this: the public positions of those on the committee were known when they were appointed, and the committee was made up of 10 publicly stated pro-Voice members and just three not in support of the Voice. That is hardly a balanced committee.

Senator Stewart is clutching at straws citing Andrew Gee “former National” to imply some sort of even-handedness. Mr Gee quit The Nationals over his position on the Voice, but I can tell you confidently an overwhelming majority of Mallee residents surveyed oppose the Voice for the reasons I have previously outlined, as has the National party.

The government achieved its desired outcome with the committee from a relatively low number of submissions, compared to the number of submissions on many Parliamentary inquiries and committees I have been a member. This referendum, if successful, will trigger the biggest change to our Constitution and expansion of bureaucracy in living memory.

On the day of the referendum, the views of all Australian citizens will be known.

My hope is that facts and reason drive the debate that informs the views and decides the vote on this critical issue, not flawed political accusations.

Dr Anne Webster

Member for Mallee

Digital Editions


  • Farrer race tightens

    Farrer race tightens

    A POLITICAL shock result is looming in the bush, with veteran commentator Barrie Cassidy declaring the Farrer by-election could reshape Australian politics. The sprawling southwest…

More News

  • Business in the spotlight

    Business in the spotlight

    SWAN Hill’s business community is gearing up for a month of ideas, innovation and connection. Swan Hill Rural City Council has joined forces with Swan Hill Incorporated and Robinvale Euston…

  • Mallee roads neglected

    Mallee roads neglected

    I AM pleased that the Swan Hill bridge passed another milestone on the long and winding road to replacement, thanks to the enabling $60 million commitment The Nationals made in…

  • Decoding adult ADHD with May Health

    Decoding adult ADHD with May Health

    MORE adults are being diagnosed with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) than ever before, and May Health, along with the Mildura Rural City Council, is holding a seminar that helps people…

  • Respect road conditions

    Respect road conditions

    DRIVERS are being warned to check road conditions before travelling, with Balranald Shire Council urging motorists to respect closures or risk long delays and costly damage. The council is reminding…

  • Glass only bin scheme half full

    Glass only bin scheme half full

    SWAN Hill Rural City Council has joined a growing revolt against Victoria’s proposed fourth bin, warning households will be hit with higher costs for little benefit. The council is among…

  • Push for funding

    Push for funding

    MEMBER for Mildura Jade Benham has called on the State Government to secure better support for regional Neighbourhood Houses. Neighbourhood Houses are run throughout the State and provide refuge and…

  • Community pauses to remember

    Community pauses to remember

    SWAN Hill turned out to commemorate the fallen and returned servicemen of the First and Second World War, and those in conflicts since. After a dawn service at the Cenotaph…

  • Coffey’s border raid

    Coffey’s border raid

    EIGHT years can feel like a lifetime in racing, but for jockey Harry Coffey, Saturday’s Group 3 Breeders’ Stakes win aboard Verzain in Adelaide brought it all rushing back. Returning…

  • Adams’ champion effort

    Adams’ champion effort

    DANNIELLE Adams walked off the green at the Bendigo East Bowling Club last week with plenty to be proud of, with the Tooleybuc bowler ending her campaign as runner-up in…

  • Sea Lake pays tribute on Anzac Day

    Sea Lake pays tribute on Anzac Day

    ALTHOUGH Leah Hobbs didn’t deploy during her army years, the experience left a lasting mark. The discipline, confidence and resilience she gained have stayed with her ever since, long after…