Home » letters » ‘You can’t have your cake and eat it to’

‘You can’t have your cake and eat it to’

WHEN I read an ABC article featuring what they referred to as “waterlogged land” in South Australia’s south-east being turned into an “agricultural engine room”, I didn’t know whether to laugh or cry.

If there had been sufficient research for this article, the author would have discovered that these south-east drains are the primary reason for the environmental degradation of the Coorong, which led to the Murray-Darling Basin Plan.

So now, we channel water from Hume and Dartmouth dams to the Lower Lakes, Coorong and Murray Mouth to try to repair the damage that has been caused by the very state that wants upstream communities to come to their rescue.

And it’s all at the cost of agriculture, jobs and prosperity upstream, in particular the mid-Murray regions in Victoria and NSW, not to mention increased prices at the supermarket for everyone.

Effectively, South Australians want the eastern states to repair their damage by demanding that undeliverable volumes are sent down the Murray River, and with clever political tactics they have conned the Federal Government into acquiescing.

The Sydney-based new Environment and Water Minister Tanya Plibersek is complicit in a plan that Australians will live to regret.

There’s a saying that “you can’t have your cake and eat it too”.

It seems that does not apply if you are in South Australia.

Shelley Scoullar,

Albury

Digital Editions


  • Fast start needed for Roos, Swans

    Fast start needed for Roos, Swans

    WITH their seasons delicately balanced after five rounds, Balranald and Swan Hill enter tomorrow’s clash knowing a place inside the top eight could hinge on…

More News

  • New Book by Siwar Al Assad Sheds Light on Syrian Minorities’ Struggles

    New Book by Siwar Al Assad Sheds Light on Syrian Minorities’ Struggles

    Siwar Al Assad’s “Damascus Has Fallen“ gives a clear, personal look into the difficult realities Syrian minorities have faced during periods of conflict. Drawing from history and individual memory, the…

  • From dreams to silver springs

    From dreams to silver springs

    THERE’S a special kind of magic required to step into the swirling shawls and unmistakable voice of Stevie Nicks, and for Nikki Canale, it’s a role she does not take…

  • You heard it right

    You heard it right

    SWAN Hill’s Country Hearing Care has been recognised among the state’s best rural health providers after being named a finalist in the 2026 Victorian Rural Health Awards. The health service…

  • Ambo response times steady

    Ambo response times steady

    AMBULANCE response times across Swan Hill remained largely steady over the past year, despite crews facing increasing pressure and longer waits for non-emergency callouts. New third quarter 2025/26 performance data…

  • Tourism town finalist

    Tourism town finalist

    SWAN Hill has once again been named a finalist for the Victorian Top Tourism Town Awards. The Victorian Tourism Industry Council awards aim to recognise and reward towns that demonstrate…

  • Saleyard turns profit

    Saleyard turns profit

    THE Swan Hill Regional Livestock Exchange is back in the black and looks set to post a profit for the 2025-26 financial year, after a reversal of financial fortunes in…

  • Final attempt to stop major works

    Final attempt to stop major works

    THE Nyah district community has taken a stand against the planned construction of levees to control the flow of water through the Murray River in Nyah Vinifera Park, which was…

  • Celebrating 102 years

    Celebrating 102 years

    FOUR generations came together at Alcheringa Aged Care Home on Wednesday to celebrate a remarkable milestone, as family matriarch Kathleen ‘Nell’ Flight marked her 102nd birthday. The milestone event brought…

  • Digital Dreamtime

    Digital Dreamtime

    THE Art Gallery of Swan Hill is set to become a meeting place for colour, memory, and Country as Josh Muir’s Forever I Live exhibition opens Friday night. The late…

  • Square set for makeover

    Square set for makeover

    RESIDENTS are being invited to help shape the future of one of Robinvale’s key public spaces as plans progress for a major makeover of the popular Caix Square. The $250,000…