Home » letters » Leaders spread referendum fear

Leaders spread referendum fear

THE lack of political goodwill and leadership in the lead-up to and immediately after the Voice referendum was extraordinary.

We were told the cynical lie that constitutional recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people through a Voice would separate Australians by race. In truth, it would have shown that we are proud of this country’s 60,000-plus years of history and that we want to grow and heal as a nation.

We were told a constitutional Voice should not come to fruition because it didn’t have 100 per cent buy in from First Australians. What a silly proposition that defies common sense and the results from individual voting booths show what we always knew to be the case. There was strong support for a Voice in First Peoples communities.

We were also told that it was Anthony Albanese’s referendum. This could not have been further from the truth. It was prime minister Malcolm Turnbull and opposition leader Bill Shorten who, in 2015, made a bipartisan decision to appoint a referendum council. The council’s job was to consult with Indigenous Australians and the broader community about how a path to constitutional recognition could be achieved.

This process culminated in an invitation from First Nations people to us, the people, asking us to walk with them. The invitation was superbly articulated in the Uluru Statement from the Heart. Last year, their request to ask the Australian people to allow an outdated Constitution to be amended finally wasn’t ignored.

With every new analysis of the referendum that appears, excuses for our failure to make sensible and much-needed change continue to roll in. It was such a small ask. Concocted arguments and a fear campaign are evidence of a superiority complex reminiscent of colonial Australia that has again played a huge role in our lack of progress on reconciliation.

While trying to come to terms with the result, I’ll continue to come back to the fact that millions of Australians wanted to walk together with our First Peoples. Millions of Australians were listening and still are.

I cannot overstate my respect and admiration for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, who have reacted to the result of the referendum with such dignity after such a challenging time.

If you haven’t read the open letter to the Prime Minister and members of the Commonwealth Parliament from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leaders, community members and organisations who supported the “yes” case, please do. It explains what has taken place during this moment in our history better than I ever could. I guess the reason why is that it comes from the heart, just as the Uluru Statement did.

Karen Smith

Swan Hill

Digital Editions


  • Record year for agriculture

    Record year for agriculture

    AUSTRALIAN agriculture is set to reach a record $101.4 billion in gross production value in 2025-26 before easing in 2026-27, with both prices and output…

More News

  • Dairy industry reunites

    Dairy industry reunites

    VICTORIA’S dairy farmers will again be represented by a single body, following a reunification agreement announced on Wednesday. The Victorian Farmers Federation confirmed that United Dairyfarmers of Victoria will resume…

  • Grapes wither on the vine as rain risks harvest

    Grapes wither on the vine as rain risks harvest

    HARVESTING of Australia’s billion-dollar table grape crop ground to a halt in Sunraysia this week as fruit growers hit by record rainfall braced for heavy losses. Flash flooding struck the…

  • Workshop to shape drought resilience funding for Mallee communities

    Workshop to shape drought resilience funding for Mallee communities

    COMMUNITY groups in the Mallee are being invited to help shape how up to $900,000 in funding is spent to strengthen local drought resilience. The workshops are being run by…

  • House prices still on the rise

    House prices still on the rise

    HOUSE prices in north west Victoria are continuing to outstrip other regional centres in annual growth. According to the latest PropTrack home price index data, north west Victoria’s year-on-year growth…

  • Mallee spared as state’s bushfire risk climbs

    Mallee spared as state’s bushfire risk climbs

    INCREASED bushfire risk is forecast across all of Victoria except for East Gippsland and the Mallee in autumn. The AFAC bushfire outlook for autumn 2026 identified a heightened risk of…

  • Books better than expected

    Books better than expected

    CASH is flowing at Swan Hill Rural City Council and the books are looking better than anyone expected. Corporate services director Stephen Fernando at this month’s ordinary meeting revealed the…

  • Art Trail installation set to begin

    Art Trail installation set to begin

    THE final piece of the River Country Art Trail will come to life in Tooleybuc, with installation of its large-scale sculpture set to begin in Mensforth Park at the end…

  • Reading between the headlines

    Reading between the headlines

    INSIDE a classroom at Balranald Central School, a group of Year 12 English students have been studying how the news media shapes the world around them. As part of their…

  • Race to replace Ley is on

    Race to replace Ley is on

    IT’S shaping up to be at least a five-way race in the Farrer by-election, with residents in the southern New South Wales federal seat to head to the polls in…

  • Raiders redemption

    Raiders redemption

    Barham-Koondrook have claimed redemption in dramatic fashion, edging out RSL in a thrilling finish to secure their first SHDCA A grade premiership on Saturday afternoon. In a match that went…