Home » letters » Focus on the good ideas

Focus on the good ideas

WHAT are the environmental benefits of Water Minister Tanya Plibersek’s 450GL water buybacks? Where is this “the environment”?

For those of us who understand the geography of where our water goes, “the environment” seems to be where it all gets flushed out to sea through what was once an estuary, past the barrages in South Australia.

So what about Australian staple food production in a drought year if these buybacks occur and water is removed from our productive irrigation regions?

Where does this leave struggling city or town folk finding it difficult to put food on the table? It’s possible that plentiful, high-quality Australian-grown food will become an icon of the past.

As a friend of mine once reminded me, “This Murray-Darling Basin Plan is madness mate”.

Why is it that our politicians are so hell-bent on hanging all of us out to dry rather than creating win-win infrastructure solutions?

In our valley, we have the opportunity to utilise an existing, natural depression called Lake Coolah located in Narrandera Shire.

This area could be efficiently used to place water at the end of the irrigation season in June and then used to water crops in spring.

This would save air space in the existing dams for “environmental water” and allow Australian family farms to produce an income by growing food and fibre.

Other benefits of Lake Coolah include increased bird and wildlife habitat, reduced impact on the already high flows in the Murrumbidgee River due to the poor management of the “environmental flows”, and of course recreational and tourist values.

So what’s stopping this damn good idea? Water corporations and even government departments find it easier to trade water to the highest bidders than to deliver it to the environment or staple food crops that feed our people.

Supply and demand drives the price wars, which creates a sense of greed for corporate management despite having grower elected boards.

Government corruption and greed is another, with many not declaring water interests and being able to have their cake and eat it too.

This greed only makes it hard for the rest of us struggling to survive, and hurts all of us in the longer term. I am sure if all parties were able to focus on the damn good ideas like this one then surely we could all be productive.

Tanya Ginns

Murrami, NSW

Digital Editions


  • Action-packed tractor pull

    Action-packed tractor pull

    THE 49th Quambatook Tractor Pull has been hailed a major success, drawing a strong crowd on Easter Saturday despite cost‑of‑living pressures, high diesel prices and…

More News

  • Speedway heats up in April meet

    Speedway heats up in April meet

    THE clay was flying off the track at the April Sonic Speedway meet on Sunday night, with crowds gathered in car boots and on picnic blankets to enjoy the high-speed…

  • Moulamein bustling over Easter

    Moulamein bustling over Easter

    YABBY races, photography exhibitions, bowls and river fun had Moulamein full of activity over Easter weekend, with visitors and locals making the most of the sunshine about town. Moulamein Heritage…

  • Family reunites for annual Easter tradition

    Family reunites for annual Easter tradition

    THE Johnson and Wright clans have returned to the stretch of Murray riverbank they have called home every Easter weekend for about 70 years. Matriarch Wendy Johnson said the tradition…

  • Golfers hit the green

    Golfers hit the green

    MURRAY DOWNS MEN’S 4BBB Stableford, Thursday, 26 March Eighty-four players teamed up for the 4BBB Stableford competition last week with Wayne Such ticking off a bucket list item for every…

  • Bustling with Easter activities

    Bustling with Easter activities

    Gallery exhibition THE gallery will be open on Easter Saturday, serving coffee and scones for anyone who would like to view the 150th celebration photos. This collection is a wonderful…

  • All abilities netball a success

    All abilities netball a success

    A MODIFIED netball program for people of all abilities has just concluded at The Stadium Swan Hill, after four weeks of foundational skills and friendly games. Participants from WeAreVivid, Echuca…

  • Water buybacks ‘wasteful’

    Water buybacks ‘wasteful’

    A FRESH political fight has erupted over water buybacks in the Murray-Darling Basin, with farmers, the Coalition and the Federal Government at odds over their impact on rivers and regional…

  • Public reminded to lock vehicles

    Public reminded to lock vehicles

    POLICE have reminded the community to secure and lock up vehicles and homes after an increased number of thefts reported in the last week. SWAN HILL THEFT OF MOTOR VEHICLE…

  • Demolition for ageing amenities

    Demolition for ageing amenities

    WORKS to remove the decommissioned Swan Hill Showgrounds precinct northwest toilet block have commenced, addressing ongoing issues and safety concerns. Swan Hill Rural City Council director of infrastructure Leah Johnston…

  • Students switch off in classrooms

    Students switch off in classrooms

    ST MARY MacKillop College is urging a balanced approach to Victoria’s sweeping school device ban, warning education must go hand-in-hand with restriction. As the Victorian Government moves to expand its…