Home » letters » Focus on the good ideas

Focus on the good ideas

WHAT are the environmental benefits of Water Minister Tanya Plibersek’s 450GL water buybacks? Where is this “the environment”?

For those of us who understand the geography of where our water goes, “the environment” seems to be where it all gets flushed out to sea through what was once an estuary, past the barrages in South Australia.

So what about Australian staple food production in a drought year if these buybacks occur and water is removed from our productive irrigation regions?

Where does this leave struggling city or town folk finding it difficult to put food on the table? It’s possible that plentiful, high-quality Australian-grown food will become an icon of the past.

As a friend of mine once reminded me, “This Murray-Darling Basin Plan is madness mate”.

Why is it that our politicians are so hell-bent on hanging all of us out to dry rather than creating win-win infrastructure solutions?

In our valley, we have the opportunity to utilise an existing, natural depression called Lake Coolah located in Narrandera Shire.

This area could be efficiently used to place water at the end of the irrigation season in June and then used to water crops in spring.

This would save air space in the existing dams for “environmental water” and allow Australian family farms to produce an income by growing food and fibre.

Other benefits of Lake Coolah include increased bird and wildlife habitat, reduced impact on the already high flows in the Murrumbidgee River due to the poor management of the “environmental flows”, and of course recreational and tourist values.

So what’s stopping this damn good idea? Water corporations and even government departments find it easier to trade water to the highest bidders than to deliver it to the environment or staple food crops that feed our people.

Supply and demand drives the price wars, which creates a sense of greed for corporate management despite having grower elected boards.

Government corruption and greed is another, with many not declaring water interests and being able to have their cake and eat it too.

This greed only makes it hard for the rest of us struggling to survive, and hurts all of us in the longer term. I am sure if all parties were able to focus on the damn good ideas like this one then surely we could all be productive.

Tanya Ginns

Murrami, NSW

Digital Editions


  • Swans press finals claims

    Swans press finals claims

    MOULAMEIN has kept itself within touching distance of the top eight after a comprehensive 60-point victory over Balranald on the weekend. Despite trailing at quarter-time,…

More News

  • Saints rise over injury hit Blues

    Saints rise over injury hit Blues

    TOOLEYBUC-Manangatang has recorded a gritty five-goal win over an understrength Kerang outfit on Saturday, with the visitors overcoming the loss of star goal shooter Zoe Morris to injury. The Saints…

  • Blues stave off determined Saints

    Blues stave off determined Saints

    KERANG held their nerve against a dogged Tooleybuc-Manangatang side to come away from Riverside Park with an 18-point win in a tense mid-ladder clash. Eager to rejoin the winner’s list,…

  • Swan Hill to host week one finals

    Swan Hill to host week one finals

    THE Central Murray Football Netball League (CMFNL) has confirmed that the first week of their expanded top eight finals series will take place in Swan Hill in late August. With…

  • Swans lead the way

    Swans lead the way

    SWAN Hill’s women’s soccer team has continued its remarkable rise, with the Swans moving to the top of the ladder for the first time in years following a gritty 1-0…

  • MRI skills boost

    MRI skills boost

    WHILE awaiting the outcome of the funding for the new medical imaging service, Swan Hill District Health is continuing to strengthen its local diagnostic imaging capability. A staff member will…

  • Unbeaten run continues

    Unbeaten run continues

    FIVE wins from the first five games is certainly a great way to start the 2026 season for NNW United, as they look towards revenge and glory. This latest win…

  • Boost for childcare in border town

    Boost for childcare in border town

    A MAJOR funding boost for childcare in Robinvale has been welcomed by Swan Hill Rural City Council, with the Murray Valley Aboriginal Co-operative set to expand and redevelop its early…

  • Council rejects industry rate relief plea

    Council rejects industry rate relief plea

    BALRANALD Council has rejected a push for industry-wide rate relief for dried vine fruit growers impacted by extreme weather, instead urging State and Federal Governments to provide targeted disaster assistance…

  • Coalition fighting for relevance

    Coalition fighting for relevance

    THE Farrer by-election had shattered the myth of the “safe” rural seat, according to veteran political commentator Barrie Cassidy, who warned the Coalition was now fighting for relevance across regional…

  • Farley hits ground running

    Farley hits ground running

    ONE Nation’s newest MP wasted no time settling into federal politics, heading to Canberra last week to learn the ropes just days after his history-making victory in the Farrer by-election.…