Home » Opinion » Don’t risk dividing us by race

Don’t risk dividing us by race

PRIME Minister Anthony Albanese has promised Australia a referendum on the Voice in this first term of Parliament. What does this mean?

At this point, we have been provided with no detail by Mr Albanese and yet it feels like we have a blindfold over our eyes and pen in our hands.

We need to be cautious about any change to our Constitution that would divide us by race.

To assume that all Indigenous people have the same desire for the Voice is to ignore the many and varied views raised by people such as Warren Mundine AO, Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price, Senator Kerrynne Liddle, among others.

This week, we saw Peter FitzSimons accuse Senator Price of “empowering racists” because she holds a different view to his own. This once again exposes an inability for open, genuine, and respectful debate.

As I have raised before, too often in politics and media, we are reduced to polarising binary arguments, part of a zero sum game. We have got to do better than this. These issues are important for us to determine as a nation.

While every voice is important, one voice should not be prioritised by default.

In the 47th Parliament, we have 11 Indigenous MPs and senators. This is a wonderful outcome of a free and fair election. The Voice would bring about a permanent change to our democratic system of government and could give veto powers to an unelected Indigenous advisory group or chamber.

As Jacinta Price has articulated, any Voice to Parliament needs to be more than virtue signalling and empty symbolism. Is the Voice required to make the serious and significant changes to closing the gap in terms of health, domestic violence, child abuse and education outcomes? These tragic and entrenched issues need a committed focused approach in order for real change to occur. There is no guarantee that a Voice will achieve that any better than ATSIC did.

Digital Editions


  • Eagles return to winners list

    Eagles return to winners list

    The Mallee Eagles have responded in emphatic fashion to their disappointing 47-point defeat to NNW United by thrashing Tyntynder by 127 points at Lalbert on…

More News

  • Satisfaction survey launch

    Satisfaction survey launch

    RESIDENTS across the Murray River Council area are being urged to have their say as part of a new community satisfaction survey launching later this month. Chief executive Stacy Williams…

  • Cancer fundraiser

    Cancer fundraiser

    SWAN Hill is set to rally for a good cause, with the Swan Hill Racecourse Bowls Club hosting a heartfelt Cuppa for Cancer fundraiser next Tuesday. Sponsored by Any Occasion…

  • Headspace marks IDAHOBIT

    Headspace marks IDAHOBIT

    LAST Friday, Headspace Swan Hill partnered with the team at Swan Hill Regional Library and Youth Inc to bring Dragged To to town, a free Drag Bingo event for those…

  • News from Moulamein

    News from Moulamein

    Mighty Magoo’s celebrate IT’S been about two years since the Mighty Magoo’s have had the chance to sing the club song, so it was a pretty special moment. As we…

  • The 19th Hole

    The 19th Hole

    MURRAY DOWNS MEN’S Stableford – Thursday, May 14 SEVENTY nine players competed last Thursday in a Stableford event played across three grades. The C Grade winner was Robert James (30)…

  • Aged care neglect

    Aged care neglect

    UNDER the cover of last week’s Federal Budget, Labor at last released shocking data on how long regional Australians are waiting for home care support through our failing aged care…

  • Rock nostalgia

    Rock nostalgia

    A POWERFUL live tribute celebrating one of music’s most iconic eras is set to sweep into Swan Hill, as the nationally acclaimed Starshine hits the Town Hall stage next month.…

  • A sequel dressed to impress

    A sequel dressed to impress

    TWO decades after the events of The Devil Wears Prada, Meryl Streep returns to the silver screen as Miranda Priestly, the formidable sovereign of the fashion world in the highly…

  • Swan Hill urged to quit for good

    Swan Hill urged to quit for good

    SMOKING rates in the Swan Hill region remain well above the Victorian average as health officials urge locals to use World No Tobacco Day as a chance to quit. Ahead…

  • Swans face first big test

    Swans face first big test

    AFTER collecting last year’s wooden spoon, Swan Hill has emerged as one of the Central Murray’s early surprise packets, charging to four straight wins to open the season and spark…