Home » Opinion » Don’t risk dividing us by race

Don’t risk dividing us by race

PRIME Minister Anthony Albanese has promised Australia a referendum on the Voice in this first term of Parliament. What does this mean?

At this point, we have been provided with no detail by Mr Albanese and yet it feels like we have a blindfold over our eyes and pen in our hands.

We need to be cautious about any change to our Constitution that would divide us by race.

To assume that all Indigenous people have the same desire for the Voice is to ignore the many and varied views raised by people such as Warren Mundine AO, Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price, Senator Kerrynne Liddle, among others.

This week, we saw Peter FitzSimons accuse Senator Price of “empowering racists” because she holds a different view to his own. This once again exposes an inability for open, genuine, and respectful debate.

As I have raised before, too often in politics and media, we are reduced to polarising binary arguments, part of a zero sum game. We have got to do better than this. These issues are important for us to determine as a nation.

While every voice is important, one voice should not be prioritised by default.

In the 47th Parliament, we have 11 Indigenous MPs and senators. This is a wonderful outcome of a free and fair election. The Voice would bring about a permanent change to our democratic system of government and could give veto powers to an unelected Indigenous advisory group or chamber.

As Jacinta Price has articulated, any Voice to Parliament needs to be more than virtue signalling and empty symbolism. Is the Voice required to make the serious and significant changes to closing the gap in terms of health, domestic violence, child abuse and education outcomes? These tragic and entrenched issues need a committed focused approach in order for real change to occur. There is no guarantee that a Voice will achieve that any better than ATSIC did.

Digital Editions


  • Rams charge continues

    Rams charge continues

    MURRAY Downs remain on top of the Northern Valley division one ladder after a hard-fought 11-shot win over crosstown rivals Racecourse on Saturday. The 66-shot…

More News

  • New era for Speak Up

    New era for Speak Up

    AN organisation that has spent the past decade advocating for regional communities affected by water policy is preparing for a leadership change ahead of a major national review. The Speak…

  • Tough times for winegrape growers

    Tough times for winegrape growers

    MURRAY Valley winegrape growers are “suffering enormously” with predictions that the current season is shaping as the worst in two decades. Extreme heat last week has only further added to…

  • Funding round open for grassroots groups

    Funding round open for grassroots groups

    GRASSROOTS multicultural and multifaith organisations have until 19 February to apply for funding through the Victorian Government to support their communities. The Victorian Government will on a key recommendation from…

  • Development boom

    Development boom

    SWAN Hill Rural City Council planning staff processed dozens of applications, approved millions of dollars in development and met state benchmarks for permit timeframes during the first quarter of the…

  • Into The Known?

    Into The Known?

    KERANG band The Known are set for their beer-swilling, swashbuckling return to Swan Hill Club next week. On their first leg of a short regional tour, the three-piece cover band…

  • CFA funding claims rejected

    CFA funding claims rejected

    PREMIER Jacinta Allan has defended the state’s bushfire funding after angry residents confronted her in fire-hit Alexandra, accusing the government of betraying farmers and leaving firefighters under-resourced. Ms Allan was…

  • Safety makes a splash

    Safety makes a splash

    VICSWIM is back in full swing at the Nyah District Community Pool. Nyah is one of the only pools in the state which offers the government subsidised swimming program for…

  • Enduring Mallee spirit

    Enduring Mallee spirit

    THREE Eureka siblings with almost 300 years of combined history, memories and life experiences have reunited in aged care in Manangatang. Louisa Gibson (102), Patricia Taggert (97) and Laurence Templeton…

  • Must win for Raiders, Roodogs

    Must win for Raiders, Roodogs

    ULTIMA-TUF will be hoping to end Barham-Koondrook’s four-match winning streak when they take on the reigning Kookaburra Cup premiers tomorrow afternoon. While Barham-Koondrook are all but assured of a semi-final…

  • Swan Hill & District Cricket Association – Round 10 Preview

    Swan Hill & District Cricket Association – Round 10 Preview

    St Mary’s-Tyntynder v Murrabit FOR the second time this season, St Mary’s-Tyntynder will be out to bounce back from a poor batting performance when they play Murrabit tomorrow afternoon. The…