Home » Opinion » Pacific visa ballot raises concerns

Pacific visa ballot raises concerns

Anne Webster

THIS week in Parliament I spoke on the value of Australia’s engagement with our Pacific island neighbours, which cannot be denied.

My speech addressed Labor’s new immigration legislation.

As those who live in Swan Hill, Robinvale and Mildura regions can attest, migrants from the Pacific islands and Timor-Leste contribute to our industries and communities – working on farming properties or in other labourer roles.

Workers from these countries contribute heavily to Australia’s horticulture workforce.

Currently, under the Coalition-introduced Pacific Australia Labour Mobility – or PALM – scheme, employers in the horticulture sector have access to a reliable workforce where there is not enough local Australian labour to meet seasonal demand.

The PALM scheme is also an opportunity for workers from partnering countries to earn good wages and learn new skills.

Now the Labor government has introduced two pieces of legislation to develop a new Pacific Engagement Visa (PEV).

Labor’s new PEV will allow up to 3000 nationals per year of Pacific island countries and Timor-Leste to be drawn from a ballot and migrate to Australia as permanent residents.

Instead of good policy based on attracting skilled migrants who contribute to the economy, the government wants to pull names out of a hat for a chance to become a permanent resident.

What’s more, their families will be brought in, with no eligibility or skills required.

Permanent residency will ensure they are eligible for Medicare and other social security benefits – unlike many other visa holders who have worked and contributed to our local communities before there is a possibility of a pathway to permanency.

We have a proud history in Australia which has and continues to rely on migration to build our workforce and enrich our nation. But a ballot system brings risk that is unacceptable.

There is no regional policy in this legislation, there is no guarantee of adding to our workforce. Indeed, day two, people could begin to rely on welfare rather than work. Thereby increasing the burden on Australian taxpayers.

Labor’s policy turns immigration into a game, with Australia as the prize.

Digital Editions


  • Swans fly home for weekend

    Swans fly home for weekend

    The Swan Hill men’s soccer team will look to continue their winning start to their 2026 season when they host Castlemaine Goldfields FC at home…

More News

  • Little gardeners play in the sun

    Little gardeners play in the sun

    FAMILIES soaked up some autumn sun this week at the third annual Fun for Little Gardeners event at George Lay Park, making the most of the school holidays. As the…

  • Motown magic hits as Big Chill comes alive

    Motown magic hits as Big Chill comes alive

    A HIT film that helped revive a music empire is roaring back to life, with powerhouse voices and a live band bringing the soul of a generation to Australian stages.…

  • Qantas growth ‘forced Mildura closure’

    Qantas growth ‘forced Mildura closure’

    MILDURA’S Qantas services will remain unchanged despite the air carrier cutting domestic flights, while adding international capacity, as it faces a potential $800 million hit from higher fuel prices. Mildura…

  • Communities encouraged to speak up

    Communities encouraged to speak up

    VICTORIAN Farmers Federation is calling on regional community members to make submissions to the Murray Darling Basin Plan Review. Consultation for the 2026 review opened on 5 February, inviting stakeholders…

  • Fuel theft risk

    Fuel theft risk

    POLICE are keeping a close watch on farm and fuel theft across the region, warning vigilance is key as farmers head into the critical sowing period. The warning follows a…

  • Homebush Rodeo rides back into town

    Homebush Rodeo rides back into town

    BALRANALD Shire is gearing up to welcome thousands of cowboys, cowgirls, and spectators to the region as the annual Homebush Rodeo makes a triumphant return on ANZAC Day weekend. The…

  • Demons get their revenge

    Demons get their revenge

    SWEET revenge came to the Nyah Recreation Reserve, when NNW United thumped the reigning premiers by 56 points. In what could only be described as a massive turnaround for the…

  • Saints continue Bulldogs pain

    Saints continue Bulldogs pain

    TOOLEYBUC-Manangatang has made an imposing statement to open the season, dismantling Tyntynder by 88-points in a clash that signalled a new era under co-coaches Robbie McComb and Nayef Hamad. McComb…

  • Fairways Festival success

    Fairways Festival success

    THE inaugural Fairways Festival has been hailed a huge success, with families enjoying a fun-filled afternoon of live entertainment and activities at Murray Downs Golf and Country Club. Murray Downs…

  • Communities not volumes

    Communities not volumes

    BALRANALD Shire Council Mayor Louie Zaffina warns the Basin Plan risks failing communities unless the review addresses the real impacts on the ground. “We cannot keep redistributing a shrinking pool…