Home » politics » Libs’ ‘phone and shoes’ housing policy rejected

Libs’ ‘phone and shoes’ housing policy rejected

MEMBER for Northern Victoria Mark Gepp has “applauded” the State Government’s rejection of the Opposition’s social housing policy,

“(Wendy) Lovell stood in Parliament and said that the Coalition favoured excluding social housing residents from certain suburbs because their footwear and phones were of a different standard and they wouldn’t fit in,” Mr Gepp said.

“I wrote to Liberal Leader Matthew Guy and Nationals Leader Peter Walsh, calling on them to dump Ms Lovell’s policy pronouncement and to admonish her for her bigoted stance – yet all we have heard is crickets.

The Labor MP said following the “filature of the Coalition leadership to rule out such a policy setting whilst still hearing from concerned social housing residents”, Mr Gepp called on Housing Minister Richard Wynne in Parliament to respond to the Coalition’s announcement.

Ms Lovell, the Shadow Housing Minister, told the upper house in March that there is “no point” putting low income, welfare-dependent families in affluent areas like Brighton.

“Where the children cannot mix with others,” she said.

“Or go to the school with other children or where they do not have the same ability to have the latest in sneakers and iPhones et cetera.

“We have got to make sure that people can actually fit into a neighbourhood, that they have a good life, and that people are not stigmatising them because of their circumstances.”

Mr Wynne said the government “completely rejected” the Coalition’s policy proposal.

“To place requirements on social housing renters in relation to ownership of specific telecommunication products or apparel would be inconsistent with Victoria’s Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities,” Mr Wynne said.

Mr Gepp said there was “no place in modern Victoria for the appalling social housing views stated by Ms Lovell”.

He said he was relieved there would never be criteria applied for social housing residency.

“As a former public housing resident for the majority of my childhood, I can tell you all we ever wanted was a hand up not a hand out and a bit of understanding,” he said. “That so-called leaders still hold views that our standard of footwear or the brand of our phone defines us is disappointing and hurtful.”

At the time, Mr Guy said the comments were “exceptionally clumsy” but defended Ms Lovell who he claims meant well.

“I think Wendy means well and made some exceptionally clumsy remarks in talking about stigmatisation,” he said.

“And I do think as a former Housing Minister, she is certainly trying to find the best contention. It hasn’t certainly been put that way. I think we all agree on that.

“Social housing, in my view, should go where there are services available for people who need it.”

The Swan Hill region has been allocated $15 million to construct social housing as part of the Big Housing Build.

Digital Editions


  • Fuel shortages hit farming towns

    Fuel shortages hit farming towns

    A SMALL service station owner in Robinvale has said his business is in the midst of the worst fuel shortages in more than 25 years.…

More News

  • Lake levels could impact skiing

    Lake levels could impact skiing

    CHANGING water levels are likely to impact recreational activities at Lake Boga, Kangaroo Lake and Lake Charm from July. Goulburn-Murray Water last week announced operational changes to the Victorian mid-Murray…

  • Birthday milestone celebrated

    Birthday milestone celebrated

    FRIENDS, family and care workers past and present came together to celebrate the joint 70th birthdays of Maureen Hewitt and Chris Neill at Ellimatta on Sunday. The two live with…

  • Fire restrictions to end

    Fire restrictions to end

    FIRE restrictions will be lifted later this month in the Swan Hill and Gannawarra municipalities after what authorities say has been a long and challenging fire season. The fire danger…

  • Stewart’s pole position

    Stewart’s pole position

    IN the busy pit lane during the Australian Formula 1 Grand Prix, technical delegate Stacey Stewart moved methodically between cars in the Porsche Carrera Cup Australia paddock, checking safety equipment…

  • Helping tidy up streets

    Helping tidy up streets

    RAIN may have delayed them, but McDonald’s Swan Hill kept their commitment to tidy up their community as part of Clean Up Australia Day. They joined more than 400 McDonald’s…

  • Man charged after rollover

    Man charged after rollover

    A 28‑year‑old man has been charged with driving under the influence following a single‑vehicle rollover. Police located the driver, who was the sole occupant of the vehicle, about 7.30am on…

  • Spot’s farmyard mystery

    Spot’s farmyard mystery

    SPOT, the lovable puppy created by Eric Hill, is bounding back onto the stage in a delightful live show designed to capture the hearts of young children and their families.…

  • Golf Notes

    Golf Notes

    MURRAY DOWNS MENS Stableford – Thursday, March 5 Just like Arnold Schwarzenegger, Rick Rundell-Gordon announced he was back last Thursday with an emphatic 40-point effort to claim both the overall…

  • Farmers short on fuel

    Farmers short on fuel

    MEMBER for Mallee Anne Webster says Mallee farmers have warned the Middle East conflict is depriving them of the fuel needed to feed and clothe the nation. Dr Webster said…

  • Rams shock win

    Rams shock win

    Murray Downs 2 have stunned their senior clubmates to claim the Murray Valley Playing Area midweek pennant division one premiership, producing a major upset in an all-Murray Downs decider at…