Home » politics » Halt ‘unlawful’buybacks: MP

Halt ‘unlawful’buybacks: MP

MEMBER for Murray Helen Dalton is pushing for the NSW Government to support a moratorium on the planned water buybacks by the federal government.

Mrs Dalton said buying back a further Sydney Harbour’s worth of water would “devastate” her electorate, calling it “unlawful”.

“That is why I am committing to work with the government in this term of Parliament to achieve a moratorium on the latest planned federal buybacks,” Mrs Dalton told NSW Parliament last week.

“If the Federal Government is worried about water for the Lower Lakes in South Australia, it needs to consider better options.

“It should look at water waste in transfers, for example. It should look at run-off and the state of some of the riverbanks. It should meter and monitor all water, including environmental water and water diverted for floodplain harvesting.

“It should consider desalination in South Australia to provide water for the Lower Lakes.

“That would be a hell of a lot smarter and cheaper than buying water from primary producers further up the river.”

Mrs Dalton said she has spoken previously after the plan to buy back 450 gigalitres of water in the Murray-Darling Basin, “diverting that precious resource away from farmers and communities like those in my electorate of Murray”.

“Four hundred and fifty gigalitres is the equivalent of every drop of water in Sydney Harbour – imagine telling Sydney that it had to give up its harbour,” she said.

“The federal buybacks will be unlawful because, under the Water Act 2007, buybacks are not allowed to occur if they adversely impact on the socio-economic needs of communities.

“These buybacks will do just that. How do we know? It is because we have already seen how devastating buybacks have been in the past.

“The southern basin has already contributed 83 per cent of the water for buybacks under the Murray-Darling Basin Plan.

“Over a 50-year period, 38 per cent of the available water in Wakool was purchased through buybacks. So what happened? There was a 71.8 per cent decrease in employment in irrigated production, while the manufacturing workforce nearly halved.”

The NSW Government should support a moratorium for a lot of reasons, Mrs Dalton said.

“For a start, a moratorium is good for the New South Wales economy as farms will become even more productive,” she said.

“A moratorium will also help rural towns and cities to survive and eventually thrive, economically and socially.

“A moratorium will also help drive down the skyrocketing cost of living that we are all experiencing right across New South Wales, in the cities and in the regions. More water will lead to cheaper food.”

Premier Chris Minns told Mrs Dalton he couldn’t “today” commit to a moratorium when asked in Question Time.

“I make the point to the member for Murray that, while we accept the 450 gigalitres of additional water for the environment was an original part of the compact between the basin states and the Commonwealth, this can only be done through water efficiency projects that do not have a socioeconomic impact on our regional communities, which is an important caveat,” he said

“I assure the member for Murray that nobody in this house, and certainly no one in the government, is under any illusions about her views and perspective, or her community’s perspective, in relation to this.

“We believe any progress in delivering the Murray-Darling Basin Plan must be done in a way that supports rural communities.

“I have been to the Murray electorate myself and met the basin communities, with the local member, in the past.

“The Minister for Water has committed to going there as well to see for herself the impact of potential changes to policy and to consider the next steps in terms of the policy iteration for this important part of the federal and state agreement.”


FEDERAL Water Minister Tanya Plibersek has invited communities to share their views about how to best deliver the Basin Plan.

“The government is committed to delivering the plan in full, including 450 GL to enhance environmental outcomes,” Ms Plibersek said.

“But, we know communities and industry have previously felt left out of the conversation.

“Delivering the plan includes achieving all water recovery targets. It means putting our rivers on a healthier and more sustainable path, while continuing to support basin communities who help feed our nation.

Individuals and groups are urged to make a submission that considers ideas or concepts could help fully implement the Murray-Darling Basin Plan; if these ideas recovered water and delivered environmental outcomes; ideas that would make a particular difference to their community and challenges or risks to implement these ideas.

More information at consult.dcceew.gov.au/ideas-to-deliver-the-basin-plan

Digital Editions


  • Funding crisis bites regions

    Funding crisis bites regions

    REGIONAL councils in New South Wales warn residents could be slugged with massive rate hikes as a deepening federal funding shortfall threatens essential services. Councils…

More News

  • Family reunites for annual Easter tradition

    Family reunites for annual Easter tradition

    THE Johnson and Wright clans have returned to the stretch of Murray riverbank they have called home every Easter weekend for about 70 years. Matriarch Wendy Johnson said the tradition…

  • Golfers hit the green

    Golfers hit the green

    MURRAY DOWNS MEN’S 4BBB Stableford, Thursday, 26 March Eighty-four players teamed up for the 4BBB Stableford competition last week with Wayne Such ticking off a bucket list item for every…

  • Bustling with Easter activities

    Bustling with Easter activities

    Gallery exhibition THE gallery will be open on Easter Saturday, serving coffee and scones for anyone who would like to view the 150th celebration photos. This collection is a wonderful…

  • All abilities netball a success

    All abilities netball a success

    A MODIFIED netball program for people of all abilities has just concluded at The Stadium Swan Hill, after four weeks of foundational skills and friendly games. Participants from WeAreVivid, Echuca…

  • Water buybacks ‘wasteful’

    Water buybacks ‘wasteful’

    A FRESH political fight has erupted over water buybacks in the Murray-Darling Basin, with farmers, the Coalition and the Federal Government at odds over their impact on rivers and regional…

  • Public reminded to lock vehicles

    Public reminded to lock vehicles

    POLICE have reminded the community to secure and lock up vehicles and homes after an increased number of thefts reported in the last week. SWAN HILL THEFT OF MOTOR VEHICLE…

  • Demolition for ageing amenities

    Demolition for ageing amenities

    WORKS to remove the decommissioned Swan Hill Showgrounds precinct northwest toilet block have commenced, addressing ongoing issues and safety concerns. Swan Hill Rural City Council director of infrastructure Leah Johnston…

  • Students switch off in classrooms

    Students switch off in classrooms

    ST MARY MacKillop College is urging a balanced approach to Victoria’s sweeping school device ban, warning education must go hand-in-hand with restriction. As the Victorian Government moves to expand its…

  • Herbie drives double win

    Herbie drives double win

    THERE’S nothing better on a balmy evening than being at the harness racing, and such was the case at Swan Hill on Tuesday when an interesting seven-event card was conducted.…

  • Perfecting the chocolate recipe

    Perfecting the chocolate recipe

    A NEW chocolate store has arrived in Swan Hill just in time for Easter, offering handcrafted treats and artisanal creations that are set to delight locals and visitors alike. Esteemed…