Home » letters » Letters to the Editor

Letters to the Editor

False promises of prosperity

I READ with interest that a business case has been completed for the Hughenden Irrigation Project, in the Flinders region of north-west Queensland.

It suggests the proposed scheme will generate $776.6 million in benefits and over 1900 agricultural jobs and will “transform Hughenden and the Flinders Shire communities into a diverse, future-proofed and resilient agricultural and economic powerhouse”.

I come with a warning to all those who think this may be an agricultural and economic panacea for that region.

More than seven decades past, there were likewise grand plans for agricultural and economic prosperity across south-western NSW with the construction of the Snowy Hydro project, Hume Dam and a magnificent irrigation scheme that would drought-proof and revitalise this land for national benefit.

Then, in more recent times, we had the Millennium Drought, which presented our South Australian neighbours with a unique opportunity to seek increased volumes of this stored water, primarily for their domestic and recreational use. Of course, suggesting the water would be for such uses would not pass the “pub test”, so instead they promoted the need for “environmental flows”.

The politicians saw a potential vote-winner, the scientific community saw a unique opportunity to get billions in funding, and before you could say “let’s hang our irrigators out to dry” the media was conned and the scene was set.

Now, instead of using water to grow the food and fibre that we all need, we provide water in abundance to keep South Australia’s lower lakes at a prime level for recreation activities, we make it available for SA’s expanding canal-frontage housing, we keep the lawns across Adelaide and other parts of SA in lovely green condition and we pour what’s left out to sea.

The communities which have relied on agricultural prosperity since the irrigation scheme was established become the collateral damage, but who cares? Not the politicians, because they have a vote winner. Not the scientists, because they have their slice of $13 billion. Not the Croweaters, because they have water in abundance. And certainly not the media, because they have yet another left wing agenda to promote.

I am pleased to see the optimism that surrounds the proposed Hughenden Irrigation Project. However, be warned, despite all the facts, all the evidence and all the prosperity, you, like us, will ultimately be destroyed if there are third parties with different personal agendas.

Alan Thwaites

Finley, NSW

Regions need addiction help

NEW and upgraded hospitals and more beds to treat vulnerable Victorians desperate to shake the insidious claws of drug and alcohol addiction will change lives and save lives.

Regional Victorians were already facing poorer health outcomes before the pandemic put monumental pressure on our health workforce.

The past two years of uncertainty and surgery bans has left health workers exhausted and forced sick people to wait in pain as they’re stuck in a line of more than 80,000 Victorians on hospital waitlists.

Labor has been in power for 20 of the past 24 years. They are the ones that got us into this mess.

They won’t be the ones to get us out of it.

Only a change in government in November will shift the focus to a policy agenda that will deliver a healthcare system that’s fair, properly resourced and accessible for us all.

The Nationals in government have promised reforms to unlock more health care workers to renew the depleted workforce, including with the nation’s largest recruitment drive.

This drive will see more scholarships on offer to enable more people to study, extra training places opened for psychologists and psychiatrists and relocation incentives to join the workforce.

The Nationals’ plan to rebuild healthcare in Victoria will also look long-term, with funding allocated for new and upgraded hospitals at Mildura, Warragul, Wodonga and St Arnaud, with more announcements to come.

It will also see a new Infectious Diseases Response Centre for Melbourne.

And we’ll make sure Victorians can access support to get out of addiction and get their lives back on track with new residential rehabilitation centres, including at the Latrobe Valley, Shepparton, Mildura and Warrnambool.

We deserve a healthcare system in regional Victoria that keeps up with growing demand and is properly resourced to take care of the health of our families and communities.

It’s time we got our fair share. We deserve a better deal. Only The Nationals in government in November will get it done.

Peter Walsh

Member for Murray Plains

Leader of The Nationals

Digital Editions


  • Fire restrictions to end

    Fire restrictions to end

    FIRE restrictions will be lifted later this month in the Swan Hill and Gannawarra municipalities after what authorities say has been a long and challenging…

More News

  • Spot’s farmyard mystery

    Spot’s farmyard mystery

    SPOT, the lovable puppy created by Eric Hill, is bounding back onto the stage in a delightful live show designed to capture the hearts of young children and their families.…

  • Golf Notes

    Golf Notes

    MURRAY DOWNS MENS Stableford – Thursday, March 5 Just like Arnold Schwarzenegger, Rick Rundell-Gordon announced he was back last Thursday with an emphatic 40-point effort to claim both the overall…

  • Farmers short on fuel

    Farmers short on fuel

    MEMBER for Mallee Anne Webster says Mallee farmers have warned the Middle East conflict is depriving them of the fuel needed to feed and clothe the nation. Dr Webster said…

  • Rams shock win

    Rams shock win

    Murray Downs 2 have stunned their senior clubmates to claim the Murray Valley Playing Area midweek pennant division one premiership, producing a major upset in an all-Murray Downs decider at…

  • Arrest for burglary

    Arrest for burglary

    SWAN HILL Arrest: POLICE arrested a 19-year-old man on Thursday, 5 March and charged him with multiple offences including an aggravated burglary in Splatt Street, multiple attempted burglaries and thefts.…

  • Australia starves without diesel

    Australia starves without diesel

    MALLEE residents and farmers contacted me during this sitting fortnight in Canberra. They are very concerned about rising local fuel prices, fuel shortages and reports that vital farm fuel supplies…

  • Riverside Harmony Day

    Riverside Harmony Day

    THE Swan Hill community will come together later this month to celebrate culture, music and food at the annual Harmony Day event at Riverside Park. The free, family friendly celebration…

  • The art of making a killing

    The art of making a killing

    BLENDING crime, comedy, and a healthy dose of moral chaos, How to Make a Killing finds Glen Powell at the helm of a narrative where ambition and recklessness prove to…

  • Anglers reel in 260 fish

    Anglers reel in 260 fish

    River to drop Normally I leave this till the river levels but this time I thought I had better put it up the top. The Edward River level was above…

  • Leadership, integrity and community service

    Leadership, integrity and community service

    BARRY RYAN ( 4 July 1934–20 February 2026) THE passing of Barry John Ryan on 20 February 2026 closed the life of one of Swan Hill’s outstanding business administrators and…