Home » letters » All talk no action

All talk no action

AT a Bush Summit in Townsville last week, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese spoke about how his government valued agriculture.

Unfortunately, his government’s actions do not match his words.

Let’s face it, Australia has probably never had a government that is more anti-agriculture.

Media reports and commentary following Mr Albanese’s speech at the summit have centred around the government’s shutdown of the live sheep export trade (which Mr Albanese apparently sees as a joke), unnecessary water buybacks in the Murray-Darling Basin and the shelved biosecurity levy.

Then there are the industrial relations changes which will make it more difficult and expensive to harvest our food.

Recent media reports have also pointed out how Australians in general value farmers, but these same farmers do not feel this is the case.

Unfortunately, this is occurring because city-based ministers, such as Environment and Water Minister Tanya Plibersek, seem to have plenty of time and high regard for fellow city-based activists but little or no time for the farmers that her Prime Minister claims are “valued”.

Ms Plibersek continues to ignore numerous requests to visit parts of the southern Murray-Darling Basin that are most impacted by her water buybacks as those with lived experience try to explain the complexities of water management and ways in which it can be effectively managed to provide sustainable farming and rural communities while protecting the environment.

With farmers and the communities on which they rely unable to have open, solution-based conversations with the responsible minister, is it any wonder they feel dejected and ignored?

As a nation we need to have a serious review of how farmers are being treated, how they feel and the reasons behind mental health issues that are being exacerbated for those who believe they are being ignored by political leaders at the same time as they work long and hard to feed families not just throughout Australia but throughout the world.

As the former Northern Territory Labor government has discovered, a failure to listen to the constituency and act on their concerns can have a devastating impact at the ballot box.

If Mr Albanese and Ms Plibersek don’t swap the rhetoric for action in rural Australia, the payback time may come when votes are cast in the first half of next year.

Shelley Scoullar

Digital Editions


  • Rams charge towards top spot

    Rams charge towards top spot

    THE final round of the Northern Valley Premier League is upon us, and it’s a two-battle for first place on the ladder, contested between Murray…

More News

  • Back to school blessing

    Back to school blessing

    ANGLICAN NEWS It was great to have students and adults bringing symbols of their planned 2026 learning to be blessed on Sunday. Along with the blessing, Rev Julie gave appropriate…

  • SHDCA Round 12 Cricket Previews

    SHDCA Round 12 Cricket Previews

    Nyah District v RSL While last Saturday’s abandoned round has all but sealed reigning premier Nyah District’s fate, the Demons will still have plenty to play for when they host…

  • Training policy axed in council clash

    Training policy axed in council clash

    A COUNCILLOR training policy has been thrown in the bin, with one councillor labelling it an “overreach and a policy that we don’t need”. The policy was designed to formalise…

  • Homecoming to Mallee roots

    Homecoming to Mallee roots

    AFTER a lifetime of exhibiting and working in countries across the globe, woodturner and sophisticate Terry Martin has returned home. The internationally acclaimed artist grew up in the early 60s…

  • Design nominated for global award

    Design nominated for global award

    A SCHOOL shaped by care is now in the global spotlight. The redeveloped Swan Hill Specialist School, designed by WHDA, has been nominated for the 2026 ArchDaily Building of the…

  • Bursary backs students

    Bursary backs students

    TERTIARY students completing placements or intensive units in 2026 can now apply for up to $1000 in support through Country Universities Centre Mallee. CUC Mallee has received a $15,000 contribution…

  • Roundabout rut

    Roundabout rut

    SWAN Hill Rural City Council Mayor Stuart King is driving change when it comes to the condition of roads, hoping for a smoother start to 2026. Cr King has written…

  • Second Mallee branch for One Nation

    Second Mallee branch for One Nation

    AS One Nation surges in popularity across the country, the right-wing populist party’s Mallee supporters voted to establish a second branch in the region at the weekend. The expansion comes…

  • Police condemn ram raid

    Police condemn ram raid

    POLICE say they are disappointed criminals targeted a “nice part of the world” after an alleged ram raid on a Swan Hill tobacco shop left staff shaken and offenders still…

  • Community worker with no fuss

    Community worker with no fuss

    CHRIS Pearce laughs when he talks about the Australia Day citizen award, a slightly embarrassed chuckle that gives him away straight away. “Everyone gets in, has a bit of a…